Mitigating the Risks of Replacing My Website

Replacing Your Website? Manage These Risks

A successful website replacement should look nicer.

Most importantly, it should better serve your audience, clients and customers.

Three main ways to reduce the risk of replacing your website are: avoiding loss of SEO, maintaining usability for existing clients and leveraging analytics about user behavior to make decisions.

Loss of SEO

Your current website may not be performing as well as you’d like but it’s vital not to lose the rankings and keywords that ARE currently working on the existing site.

To mitigate the risk of lost SEO, we recommend:

  • Making a list of all pages that currently receive traffic from Google through Google Search Console
  • Making a list of all pages viewed in the past year from Google Analytics
  • Ensuring that high performing pages remain available and navigable on the new version of the site
  • Mapping all pages that have been viewed in the past year to their best replacement if the old page will not be migrated
  • Maintaining existing link structures between pages to preserve human and bot navigability
  • Making a list and preserving/redirecting any pages receiving backlinks from other website

Loss of Usability

Your current clients know how to buy, get information and contact you on your current site. The familiarity is a factor in their loyalty. My local grocery store did a small renovation and rearranged everything due to a new competitor opening in town. Because I no longer had a familiar way to find what I wanted, it actually made me less loyal and I had more interest in trying the competitor. The worst case is spending time, effort and money just to alienate existing customers.

  • Ensure your contact forms are located in the old locations as well as any new locations you want to add
  • Ensure that old navigation structures for content and support information are preserved wherever possible, even if you are adding additional navigation paths
  • Make sure any changes to your e-commerce site are tested with a pilot group of existing customers
  • Track as much detail about user behavior on the existing site and use that to inform the development of the new site

Lack of Data Guiding Decisions

When you start with analytics on content, user behavior and site resources, you can make decisions based on what is already working and not working. We use analytics, and plugins such as Hotjar and Microsoft Clarity to see exactly how users are engaging with your website and can adjust elements that they are not engaging with as expected. Data we are interested in to deliver a successful relaunch includes:

  • Impressions, clicks, contact submissions and sales from the old vs the new website
  • Engagement time, pages visited and time spent on key pages
  • Which CTA (Call To Action) elements are users engaging with?
  • Which pages do visitors quickly leave?
  • Which pages do visitors look at before making a purchase?

Replacing your Website?

It’s critical to build on existing SEO groundwork to deliver a successful website replacement. The user experience is essential in helping visitors choose to become and stay customers. Paying attention to current analytics and behavior allows your to continually elevate their experience. Each visitor has many choices for services, why should they choose you?